Homemade Yogurt Recipe with Variations

Once you learn the basic homemade yogurt recipe, you may want to try vanilla, coffee, lemon or even tea-infused yogurt.

First, here is the basic recipe.

Basic Homemade Yogurt Recipe

Ingredients:
1/2 cup plain yogurt for the culture (must contain live and active cultures)
Half gallon of the best quality milk you can get

Directions:
Heat one half gallon of milk over medium heat, stirring often.
You are going to heat the milk until right before it starts to boil. It will look frothy and start to steam.
The milk needs to be brought up to 180 degrees Fahrenheit.
The next step is to cool the milk. Let it set until it cools to 110 degrees F.
If you want, you can cool it faster by placing pot in a sink of cold water.
Once the milk is cooled to 110 degrees, you can add the culture.
Add 1/2 cup of plain yogurt, stirring in gently.
A little trick you can use here, is to remove a cup or two of milk and stir into yogurt and then pour the whole thing back in.
Now the milk needs to set and incubate. The cultures will do their job and turn the milk into creamy delicious yogurt in about 6-8 hours.
Either pour yogurt into a yogurt maker container or leave in pot and cover. Then place the entire pot in a gas oven with just the pilot light on.

There are so many methods for making yogurt, find the right yogurt making method for you here .

There are so many ways to flavor homemade yogurt or plain yogurt, but you can also add some ingredients when you add the culture.

Try some of these variations:

Vanilla Yogurt Recipe

It's easy to adjust the basic yogurt recipe to make delicious vanilla yogurt that can be used in fruit dips, desserts, smoothies or made into vanilla frozen yogurt.

Ingredients:
1 quart of whole milk (the best quality you can get)
2 tablespoons sugar or your favorite sweetner (we like to use real maple syrup)
3 teaspoons pure vanilla extract
6 ounces of a good quality plain yogurt or recommended amount of yogurt starter

Directions:
Heat the milk over medium heat for about ten minutes or until it reaches 180 degrees F.
Mix the above three ingredients together after you take the milk off the stove.
Cover and let the milk cool to 110 degrees F.
Once the milk in cooled down add 6 ounces of a good quality plain yogurt. If you have been making homemade yogurt of course you can you that too.
Let it set for 6-8 hours and ferment.

Coffee Homemade Yogurt Recipe

Ingredients:
1 quart of whole milk (the best quality you can get)
2 tablespoons sugar or your favorite sweetner (we like to use real maple syrup)
2 tablespoons instant espresso
6 ounces of a good quality plain yogurt or recommended amount of yogurt starter

Directions:
Heat the milk over medium heat for about ten minutes or until it reaches 180 degrees F.
Mix the above three ingredients together after you take the milk off the stove.
Cover and let the milk cool to 110 degrees F.
Once the milk in cooled down add 6 ounces of a good quality plain yogurt. If you have been making homemade yogurt of course you can you that too.
Let it set for 6-8 hours and ferment.

Lemon Homemade Yogurt Recipe

Ingredients:
1 quart of whole milk (the best quality you can get)
1/4 cup sugar or your favorite sweetner
1 tablespoon lemon extract and/or 1/2 tablespoon lemon zest
6 ounces of a good quality plain yogurt or recommended amount of yogurt starter

Directions:
Heat the milk over medium heat for about ten minutes or until it reaches 180 degrees F.
Mix in the sugar and lemon extract or zest after you take the milk off the stove.
Cover and let the milk cool to 110 degrees F.
Once the milk in cooled down add 6 ounces of a good quality plain yogurt. Let it set for 6-8 hours.

Tea-Infused Homemade Yogurt Recipe

I made this with Chai tea, but you could use whatever kind of tea you like.

Ingredients:
1 quart of whole milk (the best quality you can get)
2 tablespoons sugar or sweetener
3 Chai tea bags (or another flavor)
6 ounces of a good quality plain yogurt or recommended amount of yogurt starter

Directions:

Heat the milk over medium heat for about ten minutes or until it reaches 180 degrees F.
Stir and mix in the sugar.
Let the milk cool to 110 degrees F with the tea bags setting in it.
After about 15-20 minutes, remove the tea bags. Once the milk is cool enough, add the plain yogurt or starter culture and let the yogurt set undisturbed for 6-8 hours.

Healthy Ways to Flavor Homemade Yogurt

The possibilities are endless for flavoring homemade yogurt. Your yogurt will taste better and be better for you with these natural sweeteners and fruits.

You can also save money by using your own flavoring store-bought plain yogurt.

Here are some ideas:

Natural fruit preserves, lemon curd, agave nectar, real maple syrup, raw honey, citrus zest, homemade granola or just fresh fruit.

Back to How to Make Yogurt

Return Home from Homemade Yogurt Recipe

Cultures for Health